Living A Rare Painting Purchased for Just $4 at a Thrift Store May Actually Be Worth $250,000 The painting was missing for 80 years before it was discovered alongside damaged posters and prints at a local thrift store. By Madeline Buiano Madeline Buiano Madeline Buiano is an associate editor at MarthaStewart.com, sharing her knowledge on a range of topics—from gardening and cleaning to home and pets. She has five years of writing and editing experience in the digital publishing industry. Editorial Guidelines Published on August 31, 2023 Photo: Courtesy of Bonhams Skinner Next time you take a trip to your local resale shop, be sure to look through the artwork—it could be worth a small fortune. At least that was the case for one New Hampshire resident who purchased a painting for $4 at a thrift store that is now expected to earn up to $250,000 at auction. The buyer was searching for used frames at a Savers store in Manchester when she found the painting in 2017, Bonhams Skinner, the auction house responsible for the sale, told People. The painting turned out to be by Newell Convers Wyeth and is one of four illustrations for a 1939 edition of a novel called Ramona by Helen Hunt Jackson. Courtesy of Bonhams Skinner 2 Jars Purchased for Just $25 at a Thrift Store Are Actually Worth More Than $60,000 At the time, the consignor was unaware of the painting's true value. After pulling it out of a stack of damaged posters and prints, she brought the item home and hung it up in her bedroom for a few years before stashing it away in a closet, People reports. When doing some cleaning earlier this year, she re-discovered the painting again and posted photos of it on Facebook. Painting conservator Lauren Lewis stumbled across the photo and noticed the painting had a few labels on the back, which piqued her interest. She then drove three hours to see the painting first hand, the auction house told People, noting that the painting had been missing for 80 years. The painting is currently listed on Bonhams Skinner's website and is expected to sell between $150,000 and $250,000. It will go up for sale on September 19. Was this page helpful? Thanks for your feedback! Tell us why! Other Submit